Bachelorette Ali Fedotowsky is in the middle of her wedding planning and has an extra decision to make while picking caterers, flowers and her dress. After having their courtship televised on the ABC reality show, she and her fiancé Roberto wonder if they should air the big day for their generous fans. "We got Christmas presents from all these people!" Ali says. "I know they'd love to see that wedding on TV." To keep everyone happy, Rachael suggests having two ceremonies! "We could do that,” Ali considers. “We'll see!"

In the meantime, Ali gives Rach some inside scoop on her time on The Bachelorette. "I actually kept a journal throughout the show because I knew when he was watching it would be so hard for him," Ali says. "I gave it to him at the end of the show and said, 'This is what you saw, but this is how I was really feeling.'" Rachael adores the story and jokes, "It's almost too romantic!"